Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Prisons, Nick Hardwick, gave one of the keynote speeches at October’s Sharing Good Vibrations event. His speech is online here. In his speech Nick said:
“Having now seen Gamelan workshops in prisons, talked to the workshop leaders, read the academic evaluations and tried it myself, I think the case for the value of Good Vibrations’ work in prisons and the importance of Cathy’s inspiration is made. And more than that, through my inspections, I see the value of the arts in every prison I go to. “
He quoted Tolstoy on art:
“a means of union among men [and women], joining them together in the same feelings, and indispensable for the life and progress toward well-being of individuals and of humanity.”
adding “I think is a pretty good definition of the rehabilitation we all aspire to”
He explored the reasons why it’s so difficult to get arts projects off the ground in prisons, concluding:
“In a nutshell, like the Victorians, we are in an age where the prevailing view seems to be that rehabilitation can be achieved by the exact application of pseudo-scientific processes and what matters is what can be measured. Of course the processes we want to apply are different but the mindset appears not so dissimilar.
“And that is a real problem for arts projects. By their nature they are difficult to measure, their impact is harder to describe. But in a world of benchmarking and measurable outcomes, will there still be the time for a tutor to use art to get through to a troubled boy nobody else could reach? How do you measure the value of the increase in self-esteem in a bunch of women enjoying a Gamelan course? How do you describe the benefits for the safety of a prison when a group of serious offenders enjoy themselves and communicate together in a comedy school project?”
Nick went on to quote from a speech by Churchill, when he was Home Secretary, about treatment of prisoners, including the line:
“there is a treasure, if you can only find it, in the heart of every man.”
Nick finished by asking:
“How to find it? that is the question.
“I do not believe you can find it just through offender management programmes and risk assessments. I think for prisoners, like the rest of us, art can unlock the treasures within. You all know the impact a painting, some music, a play can have on you, as audience or participant. Prisoners need the same.”